• What worked
  • What you did differently
  • Stories from when you had it
5 from 23 votes

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




Stars

26 responses to “Balsamic Butternut Squash Soup”

  1. Suzanne Sweitzer Avatar
    Suzanne Sweitzer

    5 stars
    This is delicious – a keeper for sure. I didn’t have quite enough squash so I added an apple, yum!

  2. Marie Avatar
    Marie

    5 stars
    Holy Guacamole, this soup is phenomenal.I can’t believe I’m the one that made it. And it was so easy. I can’t wait for an opportunity to impress guests with this. This is the first recipe of yours I’ve tried, my first soup in the Vitamix, and the first time I’ve used a shallot. I’m looking forward to trying more of your recipes. Thanks.

    1. Shalva Gale Avatar

      5 stars
      Love all of the firsts! It’s the best feeling knowing that YOU made something absolutely delicious (and no one needs to know how easy it was).

  3. Patricia R Avatar
    Patricia R

    5 stars
    I’ve never been impressed with butternut squash soup, so didn’t expect much. This is the first recipe I used with my new Vitamix, and I am hooked!!! Best soup of any kind that I’ve ever had, and now that I’ve been a vegan for several years, this goes way over the top of what I expected. I’ve already shared it with several friends. Thank you so much!!!
    PS My husband bought me some industrial ear muffs and I highly recommend them, after reading about the hearing damage these appliances can do.

    1. Shalva Gale Avatar

      5 stars
      Same! Butternut squash soup has always been in the “blah” category for me. That’s why I developed this one, I wanted to be wow-ed. Good call of the hearing protection, we blend so often that we use them too.

  4. Pam Crouse Avatar
    Pam Crouse

    5 stars
    Wowza! Made this today, the day before Thanksgiving, so we could have it as a first course for our Tiny Thanksgiving Feast with my husband. I hope I have enough to serve him some tomorrow.

    1. Shalva Gale Avatar

      5 stars
      Love it when our recipes make it to the holiday table 🙂

  5. Alissa Avatar
    Alissa

    5 stars
    Holy cats! This is possibly the best soup I’ve ever had! I just got my 1st vitamix and decided to try this abd I’m in love! I added roasted Brussels sprouts and shallots on top too. Yum!

    1. Shalva Gale Avatar

      5 stars
      Whoa! Those sound like excellent toppings, gonna have to try that. Welcome to the Vitamix Family 🙂

  6. Cindy Matthews Avatar
    Cindy Matthews

    5 stars
    Can beans be substituted for the tofu? If so, one can?

    1. Shalva Gale Avatar

      5 stars
      I have no idea, that’s not a substitute I would have considered. Perhaps try to match the weight, 400g?

  7. Paulette Melanson Avatar
    Paulette Melanson

    5 stars
    How many cups of cooked squash would you say this recipe uses?
    We are a soup loving couple and I’ll definitely make this come fall. We often will buy a BIG blue Hubbard or similar, do a roasting, mashing and freezing marathon for lots of go-to packages available as we want them. Please let me know so I can package appropriately!
    Thank you!

    1. Shalva Gale Avatar

      5 stars
      Great idea! This recipe uses about 4 cups of cubed squash.

  8. Jason Boehlke Avatar
    Jason Boehlke

    5 stars
    Well Shazaam Sargeant Carter, this one is a keeper, Fall, comforting, not heavy, perfect. I skipped salt, figured low sodium veggie broth and balsamic were enough and I was right, plenty of umami, easy enough to add later should you wish. I also added fresh ground pepper to my squash before roasting.

    Delightful dish!

    1. Shalva Gale Avatar

      5 stars
      Haha, thanks, Jason 🙂

  9. Lyn Avatar
    Lyn

    5 stars
    How much would I use if I was buying pre-cubed butternut squash?

    1. Shalva Gale Avatar

      5 stars
      Hi Lyn,

      It’s about 32-48oz of cubed squash. The average butternut squash (at least in our neck of the woods) is about 2-3lbs.

  10. Mindy C Avatar
    Mindy C

    5 stars
    Hey guys! Big Lifeisnoyoke fans 🙂 Making this now and see Prep says 2/3 of tofu package and Blend says 1/3…will probably do something in the middle but can you let us know?

    1. Shalva Gale Avatar

      5 stars
      Thanks, Mindy! A little confusing… the 2/3 of the tofu package is to be cubed and baked for texture once the soup is completed (like little bites of chicken). The 1/3 of the tofu package is to blend into the soup for thickness/creaminess. Hope you love it!

  11. Barb Avatar
    Barb

    5 stars
    How many pounds did your squash weigh. I bought a huge one the other day to use for lasagna noodles. There is still a lot left.

    1. Shalva Gale Avatar

      5 stars
      If I had to guess, I’d say about 2-3lbs. It been an average sized one each time we’ve made it.

  12. Lee Avatar
    Lee

    5 stars
    What type off tofu?

    1. Shalva Gale Avatar

      5 stars
      Since you blend it you really can use any kind (texture not an issue), but we use extra firm tofu for this recipe.

  13. Cook and Enjoy Avatar

    I am so going to make this. I have vegan family members and this will be just awesome.

    1. Shalva Geffen Avatar

      It’s surprisingly creamy and so flavorful! Your vegan family members will love it (bonus: the non-vegans will too)!

  14. Lenny Gale Avatar

    I was reluctant to measure the balsamic during the taping/creation of this recipe.

    But I’m glad I did. Just a small amount makes a big difference.

    I’ve had this soup twice in the last 24 hours and I can say I feel warm, satisfied, and seasonal. And happy.

    Go make it.

    Great recipe, Shalva.